An Intersectionality-Based Policy Analysis of Canadian Child Advocate Reviews of Infants, Children and Youth with Prenatal Substance Exposure and Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder in Child Welfare Care
Main Article Content
Abstract
Background and Objective
Care providers in the child welfare system often support children with Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder (FASD). Women who give birth to children with FASD face many multi-dimensional socio-structural challenges, including prenatal substance use, that lead to their children being placed in care. Alcohol use disorders have strong associations to trauma histories, psychiatric problems, adverse experiences in life, and other substance use. Children with FASD experience abuse and neglect along with other forms of adversities in childhood and adolescence at higher rates than other children, and are often kept in the care of the child welfare system. Risks of harm for children and youth with FASD exist due to distinct vulnerabilities associated with the disability. Even with child welfare intervention, adverse outcomes remain for children and youth with FASD. Our objective was to examine reports generated from Child Advocate offices in Canada on deaths and serious injuries where FASD was identified to gain a deeper understanding of the experiences of this population in the child welfare system.
Material and methods
We employed an intersectionality-based policy analysis (IBPA) framework to analyze child welfare reports from 1989 to 2019 available online publicly from Child Advocate (or equivalent jurisdiction) Offices across Canada. An underpinning theoretical framework in this research was life course theory, as it is critical to rec-ognize the connection that exists between early decisions made for infants and children with FASD and later outcomes in life. Reports were included when there was evidence of FASD or prenatal substance exposure in the report. Sequential Excel spreadsheets were employed for data extraction, and individual word documents were generated for each report specific to the IBPA framework. Thematic analysis was employed to identify themes related to serious injuries or deaths in child and youth, report summaries, and recommendations.
Results
A total of 61 reports were reviewed, and deaths of 17 children or adolescents with FASD were reported. Four categories of reports existed, including investigative death reports, investigative serious injury reports, special reports, and annual reports. Key themes from these reports for this population included: (1) challenges to stability and permanency, (2) challenges to FASD-informed service provision, (3) over-representation of Indigenous children and youth, and (4) presence of concurrent mental health challenges. Recommendations within reports addressed needs of individuals, families, care providers, systems, and policies. There were many consistencies across time and jurisdictions. One notable concern was that FASD, while possible, was often not diagnosed, and therefore supports and services specific to this disability were not provided. It is critical to note that these reports served to document both a child’s history and make key policy and practice recommendations to inform a differential response in the child welfare system in the case of FASD.
Conclusion
This analysis illuminated the risks and vulnerabilities for this population in the child welfare system and has implications for assessment, diagnosis, and practice interventions in responding to the needs of this population. This analysis also identified that many opportunities exist to improve practice and service delivery for individuals with FASD and their families. It is critical to recognize that a connection exists between early decisions made for infants and children with FASD and later outcomes in life.
Downloads
Article Details

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Copyright of articles published in all DPG titles is retained by the author(s). The author(s) grants DPG the rights to publish the article and identify itself as the original publisher. The author grants DPG exclusive commercial rights to the article. The author grants any party the rights to use the article freely for non-commercial purposes provided that the original work is properly cited.
References
2. Baby Annie. Investigative review. Alberta, Canada: Office of the Child and Youth Advocate; April 2014. Available from: https://www.ocya.alberta.ca/adult/publications/investigative-review/
3. BC Minister of Justice and Attorney General. Green paper: Modernizing BC's justice system [Internet]. Victoria, BC, Canada: BC Minister of Justice and Attorney General; 2012. Available from: https://www2.gov.bc.ca/assets/gov/law-crime-and-justice/about-bc-justice-system/justice-reform-initiatives/justicesystemreviewgreenpaper.pdf
4. BC Representative for Children and Families. Finding forever families: A review of the provincial adoption system [Internet]. Victoria, BC, Canada: BC Representative for Children and Families; 2014. Available from: https://rcybc.ca/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/rcy_adoptionsreport2014_final.pdf
5. BC Representative for Children and Youth. Monitoring brief: System of services for children and youth with special needs [Internet]. Victoria, BC, Canada: BC Representative for Children and Youth; 2008. Available from: https://rcybc.ca/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/systems_of_services_for_special_needs.pdf
6. BC Representative for Children and Youth. Kids, crime, and care—Health and well-being of children in care: Youth justice experiences and outcomes [Internet]. Victoria, BC, Canada: BC Representative for Children and Youth; 2009. Available from: https://cwrp.ca/sites/default/files/publications/en/BC-YouthJusticeReport.pdf
7. BC Representative for Children and Youth. Fragile lives, fragmented systems: Strengthening supports for vulnerable infants. Aggregate review of 21 infant deaths [Internet]. Victoria, BC, Canada: BC Representative for Children and Youth; 2011. Available from: http://caid.ca/BCRepChiDea2011.pdf
8. BC Representative for Children and Youth. Trauma, turmoil, and tragedy: Understanding the needs of children and youth at risk of suicide and self-harm [Internet]. Victoria, BC, Canada: BC Representative for Children and Youth; 2012. Available from: https://rcybc.ca/reports-and-publications/reports/cid-reviews-and-investigations/trauma-turmoil-and-tragedy-understanding-the-needs-of-children-and-youth-at-risk-of-suicide-and-self-harm/
9. BC Representative for Children and Youth. Much more than paperwork: Proper planning essential to better lives for BC’s children in care: A Representative’s audit on plans of care [Internet]. Victoria, BC, Canada: BC Representative for Children and Youth; 2013. Available from: https://rcybc.ca/reports-and-publications/reports/monitoring-reports/much-more-than-paperwork-proper-planning-essential-to-better-lives-for-b-c-s-children-in-care/
10. BC Representative for Children and Youth. Out of sight: How one Aboriginal child ‘s best interests were lost between two provinces [Internet]. Victoria, BC, Canada: BC Representative for Children and Youth; 2013. Available from: https://rcybc.ca/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/out_of_sight.pdf
11. BC Representative for Children and Youth. Lost in the shadows: how a lack of help meant a loss of hope for one First Nations girl [Internet]. Victoria, BC, Canada: BC Representative for Children and Youth; 2014. Available from: https://rcybc.ca/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/rcy_lost-in-the-shadows_forweb_17feb.pdf
12. BC Representative for Children and Youth. Who cares? BC children with complex medical, psychological and developmental needs and their families deserve better [Internet]. Victoria, BC, Canada: BC Representative for Children and Youth; 2014. Available from: https://rcybc.ca/reports-and-publications/reports/reviews-and-investigations/who-cares-b-c-children-with-complex-medical-psychological-and-developmental-needs-and-their-families-deserve-better/
13. BC Representative for Children and Youth. FASD awareness is important starting place.[Internet]. Victoria, BC, Canada: Representative for Children and Youth; 2015. Available from: https://rcybc.ca/reports-and-publications/statements/fasd-awareness-is-important-starting-place/
14. BC Representative for Children and Youth. Too many victims: Sexualized violence in the lives of children and youth and care [Internet]. Victoria, BC, Canada, Canada: BC Representative for Children and Youth; 2016. Available from: https://rcybc.ca/reports-and-publications/reports/general-reports/too-many-victims-sexualized-violence-in-the-lives-of-children-and-youth-in-care/
15. BC Representative for Children and Youth. Annual report 2016–2017 [Internet]. Victoria, BC, Canada: BC Representative for Children and Youth; 2017. Available from: https://rcybc.ca/reports-and-publications/reports/legislative-reports/annual-report-2016-17-and-service-plan-2017-18-to-2018-19/
16. BC Representative for Children and Youth. Broken promises: Alex’s story [Internet]. Victoria, BC, Canada: BC Representative for Children and Youth; 2017. Available from: https://rcybc.ca/reports-and-publications/reports/cid-reviews-and-investigations/broken-promises-alex-s-story/
17. BC Representative for Children and Youth. Annual report 2018–2019 and service plan for 2019/2020 to 2021/2022 [Internet]. Victoria, BC, Canada: BC Representative for Children and Youth; 2019. Available from: https://rcybc.ca/reports-and-publications/reports/legislative-reports/annual-report-2018-19-and-service-plan-2019-20-to-2021-22/
18. BC Representative for Children and Youth, BC Ministry for Children and Family Development. Promoting access to breastfeeding in child welfare matters: A joint special report [Internet]. Victoria, BC, Canada: BC Representative for Children and Youth; 2018. Available from: https://rcybc.ca/reports-and-publications/reports/general-reports/promoting-access-to-breastfeeding-in-child-welfare-matters/
19. BC Representative for Children and Youth, Office of the Provincial Health Officer. Growing up in BC [Internet]. Victoria, BC, Canada: BC Representative for Children and Youth; 2015. Available from: https://www2.gov.bc.ca/assets/gov/health/about-bc-s-health-care-system/office-of-the-provincial-health-officer/reports-publications/special-reports/guibc-2015.pdf
20. BC Representative for Children and Youth. Aboriginal children: Human rights as a lens to break the intergenerational legacy of residential schools [Internet]. Victoria, BC, Canada: BC Representative for Children and Youth; 2016. Available from: https://rcybc.ca/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/20120701_truthandreconciliationsubmission.pdf
21. Bennett M. On the edge between two worlds: Community narratives on the vulnerability of marginalized Indigenous girls [Internet]. Manitoba, Canada: Office of the Children’s Advocate; 2016. Available from: https://manitobaadvocate.ca/adult/reports-publications/special-reports/
22. Burnside L. Youth in care with complex needs. Special report for the Office of the Children’s Advocate, Manitoba [Internet]. Manitoba, Canada: Office of the Children’s Advocate; 2012. Available from: https://manitobaadvocate.ca/adult/reports-publications/special-reports/
23. Child and Youth Advocate, New Brunswick. More care, less court: Keeping youth out of the criminal justice system [Internet]. Fredericton, NB, Canada: Office of Child and Youth Advocate; 2015. Available from: https://www.cyanb.ca/images/MoreCareLessCourt.pdf
24. Child and Youth Working Group. FASD strategies not solutions [Internet]. Edmonton, AB, Canada: Child and Youth Working Group; 2007. Available from: http://fasd.alberta.ca/documents/Strategies_Not_Solutions_Handbook.pdf
25. Child Welfare Review Committee. Review of child welfare legislation in Manitoba: Discussion guide [Internet]. Winnipeg, MB: Child Welfare Review Committee; 2017. Available from: http://cwrp.ca/sites/default/files/publications/en/discussion_guide_mb.pdf
26. Cromarty H, Copenance S, Gitterman A, et al. The report of the expert panel on the deaths of children and youth in residential placements [Internet]. Sep 2018. Available from: https://www.mcscs.jus.gov.on.ca/sites/default/files/content/mcscs/docs/Safe%20With%20Intervention%20Report%20Final.pdf
27. Manitoba Advocate for Children and Youth. Strengthening our youth: Their journey to competence and independence [Internet]. Winnipeg, MB: Office of Manitoba Advocate for Children and Youth; 2012. Available from: https://manitobaadvocate.ca/wp-content/uploads/Progress-Report-on-the-Recommendations-from-the-Strengthening-Our-Youth-Report-2006-February-13-2012-Final-1.pdf
28. Child & Youth Advocate Alberta. Into focus: Calling attention to youth opioid use in Alberta. 19-year-old Bruce | 18-year-old Eva 16-year-old Alice | 16-year-old Emily | 16-year-old Owen | 17-year-old Gabe | 19-year-old Bethany | 19-Year-old Scott | 15-year-old Shay | 16-year-old Brendan | 17-year-old Marshall | 16-year-old Ron [Internet]. Alberta, Canada: Office of Child and Youth Advocate Alberta; June 2018. Available from https://www.ocya.alberta.ca/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/InvRev_IntoFocus-OpioidRpt_2018June_v2.pdf
29. Manitoba Advocate for Children and Youth. Youth in care with complex needs [Internet]. Winnipeg, MB: Manitoba Advocate for Children and Youth; 2012. Available from: https://assembly.nu.ca/library/Edocs/2012/000828-e.pdf
30. Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta. Mandatory reviews into child deaths, April–September 2018 [Internet]. Alberta, Canada: Office of the Child and Youth Advocate; Sep 2018. Available from: Office of the Child and Youth Advocate, Alberta.
31. Manitoba Advocate for Children and Youth. Safe for today: Barriers to long-term success for youth in care with complex needs [Internet]. Winnipeg, MB: Manitoba Advocate for Children and Youth; 2015. Available from: https://manitobaadvocate.ca/wp-content/uploads/Safe-for-Today-FINAL-1.pdf
32. Manitoba Advocate for Children and Youth. In need of protection: Angel's story [Internet]. Winnipeg, MB: Manitoba Advocate for Children and Youth; 2018. Available from: https://manitobaadvocate.ca/wp-content/uploads/In-Need-Of-Protection-Angels-Story-Dec-2018.pdf
33. Manitoba Advocate for Children and Youth. A place where it feels like home: The story of Tina Fontaine [Internet]. Winnipeg: MB: Manitoba Advocate for Children and Youth; 2019. Available from: https://manitobaadvocate.ca/wp-content/uploads/MACY-Special-Report-March-2019-Tina-Fontaine-FINAL1.pdf
34. Manitoba Advocate for Children and Youth. Learning from Nelson Mandela: A report on the use of solitary confinement and pepper spray in Manitoba youth custody facilities [Internet]. Winnipeg, MB, Canada: Manitoba Advocate for Children and Youth; 2019. Available from: https://manitobaadvocate.ca/wp-content/uploads/MACY-2019-Learning-from-Nelson-Mandela-FINAL.pdf
35. Manitoba Family Services and Consumer Affairs. Agency standards for children in care with FASD [Internet]. Winnipeg, MN, Canada: Manitoba Family Services and Consumer Affairs; 2011. Available from: http://www.gov.mb.ca/fs/cfsmanual/pubs/pdf/1.4.9_enp.pdf
36. Manitoba Advocate for Children and Youth. The 2018–2019 child death review roll-up. Winnipeg, MN, Canada: Manitoba Family Services and Consumer Affairs; November 2019. Available from: https://manitobaadvocate.ca/adult/reports-publications/special-reports/
37. New Brunswick Child and Youth Advocate. Annual State of the Child Report: Respecting the right to child and youth mental health services [Internet]. Fredericton, NB, Canada: New Brunswick Child and Youth Advocate; 2016. Available from: http://www.cyanb.ca/images/PDFs/State%20of%20the%20Child%20Report%202016.pdf
38. Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta. Annual report 2011–2012 [Internet]. Edmonton, AB, Canada: Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta; 2012. Available from: https://www.ocya.alberta.ca/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/AnnRpt_2011-2012.pdf
39. Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta. Where do we go from here? [Internet]. Edmonton, AB, Canada: Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta; 2013. Available from: https://www.ocya.alberta.ca/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/SpRpt-2013Apr10_Youth-Aging-out-of-Care.pdf
40. Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta. 15-Year-old Tony—Serious injury: An investigative review [Internet]. Edmonton, AB, Canada: Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta; 2014. Available from: https://www.ocya.alberta.ca/adult/news/investigative-review-15-year-old-tony/
41. Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta. 16-Year-old Sam—Serious injury: An investigative review [Internet]. Edmonton, AB, Canada: Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta; 2015. Available from: https://www.ocya.alberta.ca/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/InvRev_16-Year-Old-Sam_2015May27.pdf
42. Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta. Annual report 2014-2015 [Internet]. Edmonton, AB, Canada: Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta; 2015. Available from: https://www.ocya.alberta.ca/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/AnnRpt_2014-2015.pdf
43. Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta. Voices for change [Internet]. Edmonton, AB, Canada: Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta; 2016. Available from: https://www.ocya.alberta.ca/adult/news/special-report-voices-for-change/
44. Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta. 16-Year-old Dillon—Serious injury: An investigative review [Internet]. Edmonton, AB, Canada: Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta; 2017. Available from: https://www.ocya.alberta.ca/adult/news/investigative-review-16-year-old-dillon/
45. Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta. Three young children: An investigative review [Internet]. Edmonton, AB, Canada: Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta; 2017. Available from: https://www.ocya.alberta.ca/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/InvRev_Three-Young-Children_2017July.pdf
46. Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta. 14-year-old Lee—serious injury: An investigative review [Internet]. Edmonton, AB, Canada: Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta; 2018. Available from: https://open.alberta.ca/dataset/c18909d7-ff97-4733-8eab-529f3cad4876/resource/4ae48787-7f29-46fc-9dad-52b872e07e23/download/ocya-review-14-year-old-lee-response-from-childrens-services.pdf
47. Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta. Annual report 2017–2018 [Internet]. Edmonton, AB, Canada: Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta; 2018. Available from: https://www.ocya.alberta.ca/adult/news/2017-2018-annual-report-released/
48. Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta. Summary report: Five years of investigations April 1, 2012–March 31, 2017 [Internet]. Edmonton, AB, Canada: Office of the Child and Youth Advocate Alberta; 2018. Available from: https://www.ocya.alberta.ca/adult/news/summary-report-five-years-of-investigations/
49. Office of the Ombudsman and Child and Youth Advocate. Hand-in-hand: A review of First Nations child welfare in New Brunswick [Internet]. Fredericton, NB, Canada: Office of the Ombudsman and Child and Youth Advocate; 2010. Available from: https://cwrp.ca/sites/default/files/publications/en/NB-handinhand_e.pdf
50. Ontario Child Advocate. The Office of the Coroner's death review of the youth suicides at the Pikangikum First Nation [Internet]. Ottawa, ON, Canada: Ontario Child Advocate; 2008. Available from: http://www.mcscs.jus.gov.on.ca/english/DeathInvestigations/office_coroner/PublicationsandReports/PIK_report.html
51. Ontario Child Advocate . We’re all in it together. Ottawa, ON, Canada: Ontario Child Advocate; 2010.
52. Ontario Child Advocate. We have something to say [Internet]. Ottawa, ON, Canada: Ontario Child Advocate; 2016. Available from: https://ocaarchives.files.wordpress.com/2019/01/we-have-something-to-say-report-en.pdf
53. Ontario Child Advocate. Safe with intervention [Internet]. Ottawa, ON: Ontario Child Advocate; 2018. Available from: http://www.mcscs.jus.gov.on.ca/english/Deathinvestigations/OfficeChiefCoroner/Publicationsandreports/SafeIntervention.html
54. Representative for Children and Youth. First Nations girl’s tragic story shines light on systemic shortfalls [Internet]. Victoria, BC, Canada: Representative for Children and Youth; February 6, 2014. Available from: https://rcybc.ca/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/lits-nr_final_webversion.pdf
55. Saskatchewan Advocate for Children and Youth. Annual report 2011 [Internet]. Saskatoon, SK, Canada: Saskatchewan Advocate for Children and Youth; 2011. Available from: https://cwrp.ca/publications/2011-annual-report-saskatchewan-childrens-advocate-office
56. Saskatchewan Advocate for Children and Youth. Annual report 2013 [Internet]. Saskatoon, SK, Canada: Saskatchewan Advocate for Children and Youth; 2013. Available from: https://cwrp.ca/publications/2013-annual-report-saskatchewan-childrens-advocate-office
57. Saskatchewan Advocate for Children and Youth. Annual report 2014 [Internet]. Saskatoon, SK, Canada: Saskatchewan Advocate for Children and Youth; 2014. Available from: https://cwrp.ca/publications/2014-annual-report-saskatchewan-childrens-advocate-office
58. Saskatchewan Advocate for Children and Youth. Lost in the system: Jake’s story [Internet]. Saskatoon, SK, Canada: Saskatchewan Advocate for Children and Youth; 2014. Available from: https://cwrp.ca/publications/lost-system-jakes-story
59. Saskatchewan Advocate for Children and Youth. Two tragedies: Holding systems accountable [Internet]. Saskatoon, SK, Canada: Saskatchewan Advocate for Children and Youth; 2014. Available from: https://cwrp.ca/publications/two-tragedies-holding-systems-accountable
60. Saskatchewan Advocate for Children and Youth. Annual report 2018 [Internet]. Saskatoon, SK, Canada: Saskatchewan Advocate for Children and Youth; 2018. Available from: https://www.saskadvocate.ca/sites/default/files/u11/annual_report_2018.pdf
61. Saskatchewan Children’s Advocate Office. A breach of trust: An investigation into foster home overcrowding in the Saskatoon Service Centre [Internet]. Saskatoon, SK, Canada: Saskatchewan Advocate for Children and Youth; 2009. Available from: https://cwrp.ca/publications/breach-trust-investigation-foster-home-overcrowding-saskatoon-service-centre